Inclusive Cultures in Engineering 2023 provides commentary and analysis of the results of research commissioned by the Academy to better understand how engineers perceive the current culture of the engineering profession, and whether it is attracting, developing and retaining, the number and diversity of engineers we need. The report explores the relationship between culture, inclusion and diversity and, in particular, intersectional data from underrepresented groups.
Nearly seven million employees work in engineering in the UK, and the responses of the 1,657 engineers and employers who participated in the research indicate that engineers feel pride in their profession, with eight in ten (81%) keen to promote it as a career. The increasing role of ‘positive action policies’ and programmes may also be having a positive effect, the report concludes. Respondents who identified as both LGBTQ+ and Black, Asian or minority ethnic, and those with a disability who are Black, Asian or minority ethnic, agreed that diversity had improved in engineering (87% and 88% respectively).
However, to make engineering more inclusive, the sector ‘needs to work more innovatively and collaboratively to ensure that the profession is fit for the future’. While three-quarters of engineers surveyed believe inclusion in engineering has improved in the past five years, underrepresented groups are less likely to view the culture in this way.
The research highlights ‘different facets of what an inclusive culture across the engineering profession looks like, and the values and behaviours that can either enable or inhibit the development of an inclusive culture’.
The RAE said: “Inclusive working environments in engineering support creativity through collaboration and cooperation, are accepting of diverse views, and develop innovative solutions to problems whilst being informed by evidence. While there are ‘microclimates’ of inclusion, their crucial growth is impeded because of barriers to inclusion that persist. Reported ‘masculine’ and ‘macho’ culture remains prevalent in certain parts of the profession, along with ‘siloed working’, and fear of calling out harassment and other bad behaviour or of speaking up more generally.”
Underrepresented groups continue to report experiencing a profession where microaggressions are overlooked, and bullying, discrimination, and harassment still occur, the report says. Overall, one in three engineers (35 %) who responded to the survey had experienced bullying and harassment. However, when exploring intersectionality within the data this figure went up to 70% for those who identified as both LGBTQ+ and Black, Asian or minority ethnic, and also for those who are Black, Asian, or minority ethnic and have a disability.
Louise Parry FCIPD, director of People and Organisational Development at Energy and Utility Skills, and Chair of the Inclusive Cultures Advisory Group, said: “Building and sustaining inclusive cultures is key to the attraction, development, and retention of engineers in the profession, and this requires clear investment in, and leadership of, inclusion. It is great that three quarters of the engineers we spoke to feel that the culture of engineering has improved in the past five years. However, it is clear we have a long way to go. It is unacceptable that there is anyone working in our profession who feels unable to bring their authentic self to work. People need to be able to fully bring to bear their individual skills and perspectives to help tackle our many engineering challenges. Employers, professional institutes, and the Academy itself, all have a key role to play in addressing this. The recommendations the report calls for are essential if we are to make engineering a truly inclusive profession to work in, and for UK engineering to continue to be a key player in the global race for engineering skills.”
The report’s recommendations for cultivating a more inclusive profession are grouped under four themes: improving the culture of inclusion; nurturing a sense of belonging; tackling bullying, harassment and discrimination, and improving retention and success. Recommendations are for the engineering community as a whole, with some more suited to engineering industry, organisations, and bodies.